technical
the
volts are in
PROPER
USAGE AND MAINTENANCE WILL KEEP BATTERY
CURRENT FLOWING
Text
by Joel Donaldson
When
it comes to getting maximum enjoyment from your RV good "house"
batteries are absolutely essential. A properly sized, well-maintained
battery bank makes your RV feel at home virtually anywhere — even when there
are no AC hookups to be found. Good batteries can make all the difference
between having cold drinks or melted ice cream in the fridge, staying up late
with a good book or going to bed at sundown, and staying warm in cool weather.
Without adequate DC power, most of the creature comforts in your RV quickly come
to a screeching halt.
Sadly,
the house batteries are usually the weakest link among all the typical RV's
self-containment systems. While you might be able to dry camp
for a week or so before the holding tanks require service (or up to several
months between propane refills), you'd be doing well to wring more
than several days out of the typical house battery bank. Undersized batteries
are the bane of the RV industry, many of which are further hampered by improper
battery care and recharging. In this article, we'll explain how to put together
a battery bank that won't tire of dry camping before you do.
battery
types compared
House
batteries are currently available in several distinct technologies. The original
flooded-cell design uses flat lead plates that are immersed
in an electrolyte solution comprised of sulfuric acid and water. Inexpensive and
widely available, these batteries are very forgiving of overcharging, since the
non-sealed construction makes it easy to replenish any water lost to
evaporation. Although not very glamorous by contemporary standards,
some of the better brands are capable of delivering long, trouble-free service
when properly maintained.
Some
flooded cell batteries are also available in semi-sealed, quasi maintenance-free
packages. By using special plate chemistries and large electrolyte reservoirs to
reduce gassing and water loss, these designs virtually eliminate the need to add
water for the entire life of the battery.
However, the sealed construction requires tighter control over the recharge
process to avoid permanent damage due to water evaporation.
Gelled-cells are finding favor among many RVers. The use of a gelled electrolyte
makes gelled-cells virtually spill-proof, and the sealed
construction does away with any need for periodically adding water. It also
eliminates the generation of explosive hydrogen gas under normal
conditions, helps keep the battery terminals clean, and allows the battery to be
mounted at odd angles — even upside down in some
applications. As with all sealed batteries, proper recharge techniques are
essential in preventing water loss.
Like
gelled-cells, most absorbed-electrolyte glass mat (AGM) batteries are completely
sealed. However, instead of gelling the electrolyte, these batteries suspend it
inside porous glass mats stacked against the lead plates. In some models, the
plates are not flat, but are instead rolled in
a spiral around the mats. Like gelled-cells, the close contact between the
plates and electrolyte allows AGM batteries to rapidly accept or deliver
current. This makes fast recharge times possible, assuming good recharge
capability.
Most
batteries are designed for a specific application, and deliver the best
performance when used for their intended purpose.
Starting/lighting/ignition (SLI) batteries are built to briefly deliver a large
burst of engine starting current, which is almost immediately replenished
by the engine's charging system. These engine starting batteries are engineered
for maximum power in the smallest, lightest package.
However, the plates tend to be very thin, making them prone to cracking and
buckling during heavy discharges. Some flooded cell SLI batteries
won't withstand more than a few complete discharge/recharge cycles without
sustaining permanent damage, making them very poor choices for
use as RV house batteries.
This
contrasts with deep-cycle batteries, which are specifically designed to be
heavily discharged, and recharged many times without suffering
plate damage. Even the most inexpensive of these batteries will far outlast most
SLI batteries in typical RV house battery service.
rate your batteries BY
THE numbers
It's important to understand how house batteries
are measured and compared. The most common specification is the amp-hour (AH)
rating,
which defines how many amps the battery will deliver over a 20-hour period
before the voltage drops to a level many 12-volt DC appliances will
not tolerate (usually 10.5 volts for 12-volt batteries). For example, a
fully-charged battery that delivers 5 amps for 20 hours might earn a 100 AH
rating. This battery could also deliver 1 amp for 100 hours (or more), or 2 amps
for 50 hours, and so on.
Battery
|
AH
|
Cycle
|
Price
|
Lifetime
Cost
|
Type
|
Rating
|
Life
|
Range
|
Per 1000 AH
|
Flooded-Cell
Deep-Cycle
|
|
|
Group 24
|
85
|
100-350
|
$50-$90
|
$2-$11
|
Group 27
|
105
|
100-350
|
$60-$100
|
$2-$10
|
GC-2 Golf Cart
|
220
|
500-750
|
$80-$200
|
$.50-$2
|
Group 8D
|
220
|
500-750
|
$225-$275
|
$3-$6
|
Gelled-Cell
Deep-cycle
|
|
|
Group 24
|
70
|
200-325
|
$135-$170
|
$6-$12
|
Group 27
|
85
|
200-325
|
$175-$200
|
$6-$12
|
GC-2 Golf Cart
|
180
|
350-500
|
$400-470
|
$4-$7
|
Group 8D
|
225
|
2000-325
|
$450-$490
|
$6-$11
|
AGM
Deep-Cycle
|
|
|
|
Group 24
|
80
|
300-500
|
$170-$190
|
$4-$8
|
Group 27
|
92-100
|
300-500
|
$190-$220
|
$4-$8
|
GC-2 Golf Cart
|
220
|
300-500
|
$440-$490
|
$4-$7
|
Group 8D
|
245-255
|
300-500
|
$470-$510
|
$5-$7
|
SLI
(Starting) Battery
|
|
|
Group 24
|
50
|
25-Oct
|
$30-50
|
$24-$100
|
Group 27
|
110
|
25-Oct
|
$40-$80
|
$14-$73
|
Group 8D
|
200
|
20-50
|
$150-$190
|
$15-$48
|
Note: Prices
shown for 6-volt batteries are per pair
|
|
|
|
|
|
Chart 1
|
Reserve
capacity is another rating that describes how many minutes the battery can
continuously supply 25 amps of current. Multiplying the
reserve capacity by 0.6 provides a rough estimation of the battery's equivalent
amp-hour rating. In order to
estimate your battery requirements,
it's helpful to do an amp-hour "budget forecast." To do this,
determine the number of amps consumed by a 12-volt DC appliance, and then
multiply it by the anticipated number of hours of operation between battery
recharges. For example, if you use a 2 amp reading lamp 3 hours
every day for 6 days between recharges, your batteries will have to supply 36
amp hours for the lamp. Do the same thing for all your other 12-volt
DC appliances, and add the amp-hour results together to get your total AH
requirements. Ideally, your battery bank should be at least twice as
large as your amp-hour requirements,
for several reasons. First, the life expectancy of any battery is drastically
shortened by heavy, repeated discharges. For example, regularly draining 80
percent of a battery's charge will wear it out up to six times faster than
draining it just 50 percent.
Next, all batteries temporarily lose some of their capacity at low temperatures,
just when heavy use of the furnace places extra demands on them. Finally,
capacity drops off gradually as the battery ages, leaving you with less reserve
than you used to have.
Most
RVers will need more than one battery to meet their total amp-hour requirements.
Note that connecting multiple batteries in parallel
effectively adds the amp-hour capacity of each battery together, but connecting
them in series (as when combining two 6-volt batteries to obtain
12 volts) does not.
installation
considerations
It's not uncommon to discover that insufficient
space exists in the current RV battery compartment for your required battery
bank size. In the
case of minor discrepancies, it's sometimes possible to squeeze slightly bigger
batteries into existing compartments. For example, Group 29,
30 or 31 batteries often have significantly more capacity than their similarly
sized Group 27 cousins.
For more ambitious upgrades, it may be necessary to
fabricate a second battery compartment. This enclosure must provide proper
ventilation,
easy access for routine maintenance, and sufficient
mechanical strength to support up to several hundred pounds of extra battery
weight. (See Chart 1).
How
long will they last?
Although it isn't widely advertised, some battery
manufacturers publish typical life expectancies for their products. This data is
usually expressed
in terms of cycle life — in other words, how many discharge/recharge cycles
the battery can withstand before reaching the end of its useful life.
By definition, draining the battery down to 20 percent of rated capacity
constitutes a discharge, and the battery is considered to be worn out
when it will no longer recharge to more than 80 percent of rated capacity. Chart
1 describes the approximate cycle life expectancies of some
common batteries, as well as typical costs when averaged over their total life
spans.
Chart 1 shows that flooded-cell golf
cart batteries generally deliver the best bang for the buck. They also have the
advantage of being easy to
obtain (many wholesale clubs and golf cart shops stock them), and their size
allows them to take the place of a pair of conventional Group 24
batteries in some battery compartments. Gelled-cell and AGM batteries offer the
advantage of dramatically reducing exterior corrosion
(no electrolyte spillage) and, for the RV owner who demands maximum usable
capacity from a limited number of batteries, the advantage of
higher recharge acceptance (see High
Performers sidebar, end of document).
when
& How to recharge
For
maximum battery longevity, it's important to recharge batteries before they
become excessively discharged. In order to do this, you'll need a
reliable method of determining battery state of charge. Using a digital
voltmeter is one method. The voltages shown in Chart 2 indicate the
battery's approximate state of charge, although differences in battery designs
can affect these readings somewhat. Another method involves the
use of a hydrometer, which measures the specific gravity of the battery's
electrolyte. Note that this method is only useful for flooded-cell batteries
with removable filler caps. The hydrometer's suction bulb is used to draw enough
electrolyte out of each battery cell to lift the float tube off the
bottom of the glass enclosure. The level at which the tube floats is an
indication of the electrolyte's specific gravity. A chart similar to Chart 2 can
then be used to convert specific gravity to battery state of charge. Some
hydrometers or conversion charts include provisions for taking readings
at various temperatures, thereby improving measurement accuracy. For best
accuracy, the battery should sit in a "resting" state (no large
discharge or recharge currents) for several hours prior to taking either voltage
or specific gravity measurements.
battery
|
specific
|
depth of
|
voltage
|
gravity
|
discharge
|
12.66 or more
|
1.265-1.280
|
0% (full)
|
12.45-12.51
|
1.225-1.240
|
25%
|
12.25-12.27
|
1.190-1.200
|
50%
|
11.79 or less
|
1.100-1.120
|
100% (dead)
|
|
|
|
Chart 2
|
The other trick to maximum battery life involves
prompt, complete recharging. Flooded cell batteries in particular are prone to
permanent loss of capacity after being left in a dead or partially discharged
state. Gelled-cells and AGM batteries are more forgiving of this kind of abuse,
but
can be damaged by it as well. Ideally, you should fully recharge your batteries
just as soon as
it's possible to do so.
In order to fully recharge a battery in
the shortest time, a "multi-step" approach is preferred.
First, a "bulk" charge quickly brings the battery up to approximately
70 percent of full capacity. The charging current during this phase is limited
only by the size and kind of battery bank, and can be
up to 20 percent of the bank's total AH capacity for flooded-cell batteries, 35 percent for gelled-cells, or 50
percent for AGM batteries.
The charger constantly measures battery voltage,
which gradually rises to approximately 14.4 volts for flooded and AGM batteries
(14.1 for gels)
as the battery reaches the 70-percent level. At this point, the charger switches
to an "acceptance" charge, which supplies what ever current is
necessary to maintain the battery at 14.4 volts. This phase gradually brings the
battery up to approximate 95 percent capacity.
As the battery reaches a full state of charge, the current required also drops
off to just a few amps, at which
point the charger switches to a final maintenance or "float" charge,
which supplies only enough current to keep the battery at approximately 13.5
volts for flooded-cell batteries, or
13.4 volts for gelled-cell or AGM batteries.
maintenance
Since exposing the
battery plates to air may permanently reduce capacity, it is essential that the
electrolyte level in flooded-cell batteries be periodically checked. Only the
water in the acid/water electrolyte is lost to evaporation, so only distilled
water should be used to replenish it.
Batteries under light usage will typically require water every several months.
More frequent watering may indicate heavy service or battery
overcharge; less frequent watering may indicate chronic undercharging.
The occasional
application of an equalization charge is beneficial in extending the life
expectancy of nonsealed flooded-cell batteries. Some
multi-stage battery chargers have a built-in equalization function. Typically
performed once every few months, this procedure supplies a
deliberate overcharge that lasts for up to 8 hours, thereby helping to remove
plate sulphation and thoroughly "stir" the electrolyte. Equalization
may cause the battery voltage to rise above 16 volts, so it's important to
disconnect any 12-volt DC loads beforehand. Also, significant gassing
and water loss will occur, so provide adequate ventilation and top off the water
levels frequently. Equalization should never be used on sealed
or gelled-cell batteries, which would suffer irreparable water loss; AGM
batteries should be equalized annually for 1 to 3 hours while limiting
voltage to 15.5.
safety first
Battery electrolyte is
poisonous, corrosive, and can cause severe skin and eye bums. Flooded-cell
batteries can produce hydrogen gas in
potentially explosive concentrations during the recharge process, so it's
essential to provide adequate ventilation, avoid electrical sparks and
open flames. Finally, most batteries are capable of supplying enough current to
instantly melt metal hand tools or jewelry, so care should be
taken to prevent accidental contact with exposed terminals and wiring. Always
wear face, hand and clothing protection when working around
batteries. TL
SOURCES
AC
Delco; (810) 257-8512, www.acdelco.com
. circle 222 ON reader
service card.
East
Penn Mfg. Co. Inc.; (610) 682-6361, www.eastpenn-deka.com.
circle 223 on
reader service card.
Exide
Corp.; (610) 378-0500, www.exide.com
. circle 224 on
reader service card.
Interstate
Battery System Of America; (972)
991-144, www.interstatebatteries.com.
circle 225 on
reader SERVICE CARD.
Lifeline Batteries; (626) 969-6886,
www.lifelinebatteries.com.
circle 226 on
reader service card.
Optima
Batteries Inc.; (303) 340-7440, www.optimabatteries.com
. circle 227 on reader service card.
Thermoil;
(407) 786-7479, www.thermoilbatteries.com
circle 228 on
reader service card.
Trojan
Battery Co.; (800) 423-6569, www.trojan-battery.com
. circle 229 on reader service card.
WestCo
Battery Systems Inc.; (800) 214-8040, www.westcobattery.com
. circle 230 on reader service card.
high performers
RV
owners who hook up in RV parks most of the time may not know the difference
between a car battery and a top-notch RV deep cycle battery.
The boondocker, however, undoubtedly has seen the lights go dim around 10p.m. on
a chilly evening after several hours of using 12-volt DC
appliances, and the battery question becomes connected to the challenge of
staying warm through the night.
Deep-cycle
batteries of good quality and capacity are the answer (see main article). For
the owner who wants the racehorse of the deep-cycle
breed — the battery that lasts the longest and can be recharged the fastest
— absorbed glass mat (AGM) batteries fit the description.
Lifeline
AGM batteries, developed originally for military aircraft, are available in
various popular sizes, including the Group 27 unit featured here,
and they offer several advantages over gelled-cell and conventional flooded
lead-add batteries. The most important aspect for the boondocker is low internal
resistance (recharge current lost to gassing or breaking up of water). Batteries
with this capability can be charged rapidly from typical
sources, including solar panels, an AC generator (via a converter/inverter) or
an alternator while driving.
Conventional
flooded batteries have the highest resistance, listed by Lifeline at 26 percent
or higher (the battery must be charged to 126 percent
of rated capacity to achieve full recharge); gel batteries are listed at 16
percent and AGM batteries at 2 percent. Lifeline claims that this
translates to 20 to 25 percent faster recharge than conventional flooded or
gelled-cell batteries.
Maximum charging voltage is about the same as that
recommended for flooded batteries — 14.4 volts at 70 degrees ambient
temperature —
with no amperage maximum as long as
voltage limits are observed. Maximum recommended recharge voltage for gel
batteries at the same temperature is 14.1, so they are more easily overcharged,
according to Lifeline.
As
one might expect, high performance is not cheap. The Lifeline AGM units are
priced substantially higher than conventional flooded-cell
batteries ($ 162 for a Lifeline Group 27 battery, rated at 100 amp hours, or
reserve capacity of 186 minutes at the 25-amp rate), but they offer a
number of advantages. In addition
to fast recharge capability, they offer extended life-cycle durability (the
number of times the battery can go
through discharge/recharge cycles without serious deterioration), a very low
self-discharge rate while in storage and no venting of explosive
hydrogen gases.
Lifeline batteries ore sealed, with the electrolyte
held in place by silica gloss mat, which allows oxygen produced during charging
to recombine
into water rather than being expelled. Thus, there can be no spillage of
electrolyte, and the battery can be mounted in any position. It has the
ability to handle relatively large loads with comparatively little voltage drop
even after substantial power has been drown out.
The
fast-recharge attributes of Lifeline batteries are exceptional in the deep-cycle
battery field, not to mention the other advantages. This kind of performance is
what it takes to keep the lights on, the furnace working and all the toys in
motion while camping without hookups. — TL
Lifeline
Batteries; (800) 527-3224, www.lifelinebatteries.com
.
|